Algerian Education between the Success of Mass Provision and the Crisis of Learning Quality — Noureddine HALKOUM
Contents
- Introduction
- Part 1: The Conceptual Framework — How Do We Measure Education?
- Part 2: Education in the World since 1945 — A Comparative Historical Framework
- Part 3: What Has International Comparison Taught Us?
- Part 4: How the Algerian School Took Shape — A Historical Reading from 1962 to the Present
- Part 5: Algeria as a Baseline — What We Know and What We Do Not
- Part 6: Where Do the Problems of Algerian Education Lie? Six Areas of Concern
- Part 7: What Explains Differences in the Level of Education? Factors and a Causal Model
- 7.1 An Explanatory Framework in Five Links
- 7.2 The Factors by Analytical Importance
- 7.3 Living Standards and the Level of Education
- 7.4 Class Size: Do Smaller Classes Yield Better Learning?
- 7.5 The Teacher: Pay, Qualification and Professional Stability
- 7.6 Public Spending: Does More Money Mean Better Quality?
- 7.7 National Independence, Academic Freedom and Institutions
- 7.8 School Safety and Social Behaviour
- 7.9 Scientists and Gifted Individuals: Can They Be Linked to Their Schools?
- Part 8: Why Do Educational Reforms Stall? The Deeper Causes
- Part 9: What Risks Threaten Algerian Education if the Problems Persist?
- Part 10: Realistic Solutions That Suit Algeria without Colliding with Social Identity or State Choices
- 10.1 Solution One: Prioritising Reading and Mathematics in the Early Years
- 10.2 Solution Two: Lightening the Curricular Load Rather Than Adding Programmes
- 10.3 Solution Three: Developing Teachers through In-School Training
- 10.4 Solution Four: Addressing Overcrowding Where It Does the Most Harm to Learning
- 10.5 Solution Five: A Graduated and Clear National Language Policy
- 10.6 Solution Six: Rebuilding Assessment and Examinations Gradually
- 10.7 Solution Seven: Linking Spending More Closely to Results
- 10.8 Solution Eight: Strengthening Vocational Education and Linking It to Production
- 10.9 Solution Nine: Building an Independent National System for Assessing Learning
- Part 11: A Five-Year Implementation Plan and the Question of Resistance
- Part 12: What Should Algeria Not Import? Distinguishing Real Causes from Comfortable Explanations
- Part 13: The Final Judgement — What Is Algeria’s Highest Priority?
- Conclusion
- References
Introduction
Has Algeria Built the School but Not, to the Same Degree, the Learner?
Few questions bear more heavily on Algeria’s future than that of education. Since independence, the state has extended a vast network of schools and opened classroom doors to millions of children. Yet it still confronts a stubborn problem: the quality of what is actually learned, the readiness of graduates for working life and scientific inquiry, and the capacity of the school to form independent minds able to analyse and to innovate.
This question cannot be settled by repeating that Algerian education is poor, nor by defending it merely because it is free and widely available. Both positions overlook part of the truth, and both substitute a ready-made impression for analysis. Public debate about schooling too often oscillates between a discourse that reads every indicator as a sign of collapse and one that reads every statistic as proof of achievement. Between the two, the questions that truly deserve to be asked are lost: What does a child actually learn? At what point does the child begin to fall behind? Why? And what can be changed at reasonable cost and within a reasonable time?
Algeria achieved a significant social accomplishment when it made public education a cornerstone of state-building and widened access to learning after independence. But widening access to the school is not the same as guaranteeing mastery of reading, mathematics and science, and holding a school or university certificate does not necessarily mean possessing the skills that working life demands. This is the central paradox of the present article: a school system that has expanded enormously, and a question about the quality of learning that remains unresolved.
Historical data published by UNICEF and the World Bank indicate that Algeria has expanded enrolment considerably, while challenges persist in the completion of educational stages and in the quality of learning. A World Bank brief published in 2022, drawing on older data, put learning poverty in Algeria at roughly 67.9 per cent. This is an important historical indicator, but it is not an estimate of the situation in 2026. Nor does it mean that this proportion of children cannot read at all; it means that they fell short of the minimum reading threshold defined by the methodology employed.
The Argument of the Article
This is an analytical thesis that can be tested; it is not a verdict that every school, teacher or pupil faces the same difficulty. Algeria has institutions, talents and successful experiments, and the disparities between schools, regions and educational stages make sweeping generalisation both unfair and unscientific. The thesis is also open to correction: every explanation offered in the following pages is an analytical hypothesis that requires up-to-date national data before it can become a basis for decision.
The Questions the Article Addresses
- 1. What distinguishes enrolment, completion of educational stages and the acquisition of real skills, and how does this distinction shape the reading of the Algerian case?
- 2. What has international comparison since the end of the Second World War taught us about the factors that raise or impede the quality of learning?
- 3. How did the Algerian school take shape historically, and where does the fault line lie between quantitative expansion and quality?
- 4. What are the six major problem areas, and how strong is the available evidence for each?
- 5. Why do educational reforms stall, and what risks follow if the problems persist?
- 6. Which realistic solutions suit Algeria without colliding with its identity or the state’s choices, and how might they be implemented over five years?
Method and Its Limits
The article adopts a comparative analytical approach that draws on history, education policy and the economics of education. It does not seek to rank countries by test results, since the available indicators do not permit such a ranking. It seeks instead to explain why some systems advance while others falter, and then to identify what can be adapted to Algerian realities. The comparison covers a broad sample of roughly forty countries across all continents, used as a reference for understanding variation rather than as a league table running from best to worst.
The article observes a strict rule separating statistical fact from causal explanation. Whenever a figure is cited, it is accompanied by what it measures, its year and its limitations. Whenever an explanation is advanced, it is described as a hypothesis or a tentative inference, unless strong evidence supports it. Where the Algerian indicators are historical rather than recent measurements for 2026, this is stated in the relevant place.
Part 1: The Conceptual Framework — How Do We Measure Education?
Before speaking of the success or failure of a school, we must decide what success means. Debates about education often founder because the participants use the word “education” in three different senses and then disagree about the outcome because they never agreed on the meaning.
1.1 Three Levels of Educational Outcome
A. Access to Education
The first question is whether children enter school and stay in it through the basic and secondary stages. It is measured by enrolment, attendance, completion and dropout rates. This level is necessary but insufficient, for a child may spend years in school without acquiring what those years are supposed to provide.
B. The Quality of Learning
The second question is whether pupils can read with understanding, calculate and reason scientifically, rather than merely pass examinations. It is measured by independent international and national assessments that probe actual skills. This level separates a school that produces large numbers of graduates from one that produces learners.
C. Scientific and Economic Outcomes
The third question is whether learning is converted into researchers, engineers, physicians, skilled craftspeople and productive, innovative institutions. This is a long-range level, shaped by factors beyond the school, including universities, research funding, labour markets and migration.
These three levels are linked, but they are not one and the same. A country may achieve wide school enrolment while a large share of its children remain below the minimum standard of reading and comprehension. This is why the World Bank measures the problem through “learning poverty”, an indicator that combines being out of school with failing to reach a minimum reading proficiency at the age of ten.
1.2 Four Layers of Analysis
To understand why outcomes differ among countries, the article analyses education across four interlocking layers:
Table 1: Four layers for analysing the educational phenomenon
| Layer | What it comprises |
|---|---|
| The structure of education | Public and private provision, compulsory schooling, enrolment, quality of learning, school dropout, pupil density in classrooms |
| Economy and social conditions | Living standards, teachers’ incomes, public spending, availability of books, laboratories and equipment, disparities between regions and social groups |
| Scientists and innovation | The relationship between a scientist’s first school and later stages of education, the universities and research centres that shaped them, and the conditions that enabled innovation |
| History, politics and society | Independence and colonialism, war and reconstruction, freedoms, institutional stability, curricula, and the transformations of education systems since 1945 |
A basic methodological rule follows from this view: higher national income cannot be taken as sufficient proof of the quality of a country’s schools, and a large number of scientists cannot be taken, on its own, as proof of the quality of basic education. The links among these factors can be understood only by taking into account time, demographic differences, migration, funding and academic selection.
1.3 The Limits of International Indicators
The Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), administered by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), is among the most important references for comparing education systems. It measures the performance of fifteen-year-olds in mathematics, reading and science. Yet it does not capture every dimension of education, and it cannot by itself yield a judgement on the quality of a school or on a country’s capacity to train scientists. Participation is also uneven: Algeria took part in 2015 but not in the 2022 cycle, which rules out placing it directly alongside the results of that cycle.
For this reason, no single ranking of countries can responsibly be built on PISA alone. The sounder method is to use its results where available, to draw on UNESCO, World Bank and national data elsewhere, and to accept that differences in years and definitions impose lasting caution on every numerical comparison.
One further distinction is indispensable: that between correlation and causation. That higher spending coincides with better results in a given country does not mean that spending is the cause; both may flow from a third factor such as institutional stability. This caveat applies to everything that follows on class size, salaries, expenditure and language.
Part 2: Education in the World since 1945 — A Comparative Historical Framework
Present-day schools cannot be understood without the history of each country. The school inherited by a newly independent state does not resemble the one an industrial power rebuilt after war, nor the one an Asian economy fashioned amid rapid industrialisation. The five phases below offer a general frame for understanding; they are not a single path that every country followed.
2.1 1945–1960: Reconstruction and the Onset of Expansion
European states rebuilt their institutions after the Second World War, while Asian and African countries entered varied phases of national liberation and the construction of educational systems. In 1963, as education expanded and the need to plan it grew, UNESCO established the International Institute for Educational Planning, a sign that education was passing from a local concern to a subject of national and international planning.
2.2 1960–1980: Expanding Education and Forming Cadres
Schools and universities grew in many countries, among them Algeria after its independence in 1962, and other Asian and African states. The prevailing aim was mass provision and the training of the cadres that a new state required. Yet expanded enrolment does not by itself secure the quality of learning, which depends on how quickly teachers can be trained, on the resources available, and on language and curricula.
2.3 1980–2000: Economic and Technological Reform
In several East Asian economies, education became tightly bound to industrial and technological development and formed part of a clear productive strategy. Elsewhere, debt crises, wars, conflict and weak administrative capacity undermined the continuity of educational services, and states struggled to preserve what earlier decades had built.
2.4 2000–2019: The Turn to the Quality of Learning
Success was no longer measured merely by counting schools and pupils. Attention turned to levels of reading, mathematics and science, to disparities among schools, and to accountability for results. International assessments became a common language for comparing systems, and with them emerged the notion of a “learning crisis”: children who attend school without acquiring basic skills there.
2.5 2020–2026: Recovery from the Pandemic and the Digital Turn
The school closures of the COVID-19 pandemic brought the challenge of learning loss, uneven access to the internet and devices, and differences in families’ ability to compensate for what was missed. The pace of recovery varies between countries and between social groups within a single country. At the same time, digitalisation raised new questions about the role of the teacher and about the difference between owning devices and improving learning.
The date of independence alone does not explain success or stagnation. What matters is how educational institutions were built after independence, how policies endured or changed, and how resources were distributed. These three questions will recur when the Algerian experience is examined.
Part 3: What Has International Comparison Taught Us?
International comparison shows that Algeria is under no obligation to choose between one model and another. Some countries have built strong education through quite different routes: Japan and South Korea in East Asia, Finland in Europe, Viet Nam in South-East Asia, and others that developed particular strengths despite limited resources. Comparison also shows that countries do not advance in the same way, and that importing an educational policy from elsewhere without understanding the conditions that produced it can yield disappointing results.
3.1 What the PISA 2022 Results Say
In PISA 2022, Japan scored 536 in mathematics and South Korea 527, against an OECD average of 472. Singapore scored 575, Finland 484 and Qatar 414.
Table 2: Mean mathematics scores in PISA 2022 for selected systems
| Education system | Mean mathematics score, PISA 2022 |
|---|---|
| Singapore | 575 |
| Japan | 536 |
| South Korea | 527 |
| Finland | 484 |
| OECD average | 472 |
| Qatar | 414 |
Source: OECD, PISA 2022 Results. The scores are a point of reference and not a comprehensive measure of the quality of an education system.
These figures do not show that the Japanese or Korean systems are superior in every respect. They indicate that the pupils who took part in them demonstrated a high level of the mathematical skills the test measures. Qatar’s case teaches a different lesson: abundant economic resources alone do not guarantee the learning levels of the highest-performing systems. The essential point is that a school’s success is measured not simply by the number of pupils enrolled, nor by spending alone, but by what pupils actually learn and by the system’s ability to assure a sound minimum of skills for the majority of children.
Nor should these results be used to rank every country in the sample. Algeria and several other countries do not have PISA 2022 results that are comparable within the same cycle. Substitute indicators that are as consistent as possible must therefore be used, rather than assigning hypothetical scores or issuing an unsupported ranking.
3.2 Strong Systems Worth Studying
Japan: Strength in Foundational Skills and School Organisation
PISA 2022 showed high performance in mathematics and science. Japan is a useful case for studying the quality of teaching, the coherence of curricula, educational expectations, and the role of the school in building foundational skills. What Algeria can take from it is a strengthening of the fundamentals of reading and arithmetic, sustained practice, and the monitoring of each pupil’s progress, not a wholesale reproduction of Japanese school culture.
South Korea: High Attainment and Investment in Education
South Korea exceeded the OECD average in mathematics, reading and science, and 84 per cent of its pupils reached the baseline level in mathematics in PISA 2022, against 69 per cent on average across the OECD. Academic success, however, does not mean the system is free of problems; academic pressure and reliance on supplementary tutoring are issues to weigh before transferring any part of the experience. For Algeria the lesson is to raise educational expectations while providing genuine support within the school, rather than pushing families to shoulder the cost of a parallel education.
Finland: Teacher Preparation and Equity
Finland offers a model for studying teacher education, professional autonomy, support for pupils, and assessment that does not rest solely on high-stakes testing. Even so, it has faced difficulties in the results of some assessments in recent years, which shows that historical success does not guarantee stable performance. For Algeria, the relevant lessons are better practical training for teachers, early support for struggling pupils, and narrower gaps between schools.
Viet Nam: Making the Most of Relatively Limited Resources
In PISA 2022, 72 per cent of participating pupils in Viet Nam reached Level 2 or above in mathematics, 77 per cent in reading and 79 per cent in science. The mathematics results of socio-economically disadvantaged pupils were strong compared with those of pupils in similar circumstances internationally. It must be noted that the OECD cautioned about certain limits on comparability, particularly in reading, and that the 2022 results cannot be compared directly with Viet Nam’s earlier cycles. For Algeria, the value lies in studying how foundational skills are built, how pupils’ progress is tracked and how struggling learners are supported, without assuming that good results make every aspect of the Vietnamese system exemplary.
These models differ in politics, culture and economy. What they share, and what deserves study, is not a single recipe but an attention to real skills, to the quality of teaching, to the continuity of policy, and to the school’s ability to address learning difficulties.
3.3 Countries Facing the Gravest Challenges
It is imprecise to describe an entire country as having “the worst education” without specifying the indicator and the year. It is possible, however, to identify countries in the sample that face acute challenges along one or more of the following axes:
Table 3: Countries facing acute challenges in education indicators
| Country or group | Challenges worth examining | What should be compared |
|---|---|---|
| Niger, Chad and Mali | Poverty, difficulty of access to school, limited educational resources, geographic disparity | Completion, children’s reading ability, availability of teachers |
| Somalia | Institutional fragility, conflict, difficulty of regular access to education | Enrolment and attendance, regional differences, continuity of study |
| Haiti | Political, security and economic crises, disrupted educational continuity | Actual school days, dropout, ability to finance schools |
| Nigeria | Wide regional disparity, challenges of access and learning, insecurity in some areas | Regional and gender differences, reading and numeracy skills |
| Democratic Republic of the Congo | Unequal access, resource pressures, infrastructure problems | Enrolment and completion, availability of schools, teachers and basic services |
These are countries facing serious problems; this is not a final ranking from worst to best. Indicators differ in year and coverage, and performance varies sharply within a single country. International education databases stress the importance of distinguishing access to school, completion of stages, acquisition of skills, and equity in the distribution of opportunity.
Most important for Algeria is that it should not compare itself only with the wealthiest countries, nor only with those suffering the worst crises. The first comparison reveals what it can aspire to; the second helps define the floor below which educational services must not fall. Neither replaces comparison of Algerian performance with countries whose income, population and institutional capacity are closer to its own.
3.4 A Regional Map for Comparison
To ease reading, the countries in the sample are grouped regionally. The groupings are not a ranking of educational quality; they are a means of understanding differences of historical and economic circumstance.
Table 4: A regional map for comparison
| Region | Countries included | Key historical themes |
|---|---|---|
| East Asia | China, Japan, North Korea, South Korea | Industrialisation, the role of the state, examinations, scientific education, differing political systems |
| South and South-East Asia | Viet Nam, Bangladesh, India | Population density, school expansion, poverty, regional disparity, private education |
| The Gulf and Arabian Peninsula | United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Saudi Arabia | Public funding, recruitment of expertise, university development, economic diversification |
| North Africa | Egypt, Libya, Tunisia, Morocco, Algeria | Colonial legacy, Arabisation and foreign languages, mass expansion, uneven quality of learning |
| Europe | France, Germany, Finland, Sweden, United Kingdom | Teacher preparation, public funding, vocational education, governance and equity |
| North America | United States, Canada, Mexico | Decentralisation, regional disparity, research universities, social inequality |
| Central and South America | Panama, Haiti, Venezuela, Colombia, Brazil, Argentina | Class inequality, funding, economic crises, continuity of schooling |
| Oceania | Fiji, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea | Geography and islands, difficulty of access, regional disparity |
| Sub-Saharan Africa | South Africa, Congo, Namibia, Kenya, Somalia, Ethiopia, Cameroon, Nigeria, Ghana, Mali, Niger, Chad | Colonial legacy, multilingualism, rural–urban disparity, conflict, scarcity of resources |
3.5 Public and Private Education: What Should Be Compared?
It is not enough to know the proportion or number of private schools, for the models differ profoundly. In one, public funding predominates: the state bears principal responsibility for financing schools, setting admission rules and providing teachers. In a second, the model is mixed: government schools coexist with independent private schools, and sometimes with private schools that receive public support. In a third, families bear a considerable share of the cost of schooling, which may produce wide disparities of opportunity.
Each model should be assessed through four questions. Can a child obtain a good education irrespective of family income? Are there large differences between the results of public and private school pupils once social background is taken into account? Do private schools add real quality, or do they benefit chiefly from selecting the more advantaged pupils? And does the spread of private education relieve pressure on public schools, or draw away some of their teachers, resources and pupils?
Ownership of a school must also not be confused with its financing: a school may be privately managed yet publicly subsidised, or public while families pay additional costs for private tutoring. In the Algerian case, the effect of private tutoring must be examined alongside private schools, because tutoring may create a parallel educational system even where schooling itself is public.
Part 4: How the Algerian School Took Shape — A Historical Reading from 1962 to the Present
4.1 The Colonial Legacy: An Unequal Point of Departure
When Algeria became independent in 1962, the state did not begin with a comprehensive education system offering equal opportunity. Under colonial rule, access to schooling had been restricted for the great majority of Algerians, and education was organised to serve the priorities of the colonial power. After independence the state faced an immense task: building national schools, training teachers, widening enrolment, and reshaping curricula and educational identity.
It would therefore be unjust to compare Algeria directly with Finland or Japan today and conclude from the present gap that Algerians are less capable, or that the Algerian school was doomed to fail from the outset. The countries with which it is compared began from very different positions: some possessed industrial institutions and well-established universities, some emerged from war and occupation, and some lacked even the basic school infrastructure.
Yet the colonial legacy, however deep its effects, cannot by itself explain the state of education more than six decades after independence. Once the foundational phase was over, national decisions on teacher training, the organisation of curricula, school management, the evaluation of results and the continuity of reform became factors that cannot be exempted from criticism. The first historical problem, then, is that Algeria inherited a severe educational deficit; the second is how far it succeeded in converting quantitative expansion into lasting quality.
4.2 Arabisation and the Building of National Identity: A Historical Necessity and a Pedagogical Challenge
The restoration of Arabic in the school formed part of the recovery of cultural sovereignty after colonialism. Arabisation was never a merely technical choice about teaching methods; it was bound up with national identity, political legitimacy and social justice. Historical studies document the spread of Arabisation from the 1960s, its deepening in the 1970s, and the later introduction of the basic school and other reforms, and they show that French continued in some scientific and technical fields and in higher education.
Two extreme positions should be avoided. The first holds that Arabisation is, in itself, a sufficient cause of educational decline. International comparison alone does not support this conclusion: countries can teach in their national languages and achieve strong results when they provide good scientific content, clear terminology, suitable textbooks and effective teacher training. The second assumes that the choice of language of instruction has no consequence for learning science or following international research. That, too, is unrealistic, for movement between languages, if not accompanied by genuine linguistic competence and suitable scientific resources, may add a burden for the student.
What deserves criticism is neither the national standing of Arabic nor the need to learn foreign languages, but the way multilingualism is managed along the educational pathway. A student who learns science in Arabic and then needs to consult university literature in another language must possess real competence in both, not a nominal familiarity with terms. A student learning French or English should not do so at the expense of a deep grasp of the subject matter.
A policy consistent with national identity is a graduated language policy: strong Arabic in comprehension, expression and knowledge, together with serious teaching of foreign languages as instruments of access to science and technology, and coordination of terminology and textbooks across stages of education. There is no need to make language a permanent battleground at the expense of attainment.
4.3 The Expansion of Education: A Social Achievement Not to Be Denied
It is only fair to acknowledge that Algeria has built an extensive school system, that millions of children benefit from education, and that the state continues to carry heavy responsibility for financing it. According to UNICEF’s 2024 annual report on Algeria, more than 11 million children were enrolled in school in the 2024–2025 school year, and UNICEF estimated public spending on education at about 6.3 per cent of gross domestic product.
These figures matter, but they do not settle the question of quality. Enrolment measures entry into the system, expenditure measures the resources allocated to it, while learning is measured by the skills and knowledge a pupil acquires. A state can build many schools; but without a capable teacher, a clear textbook, sufficient time for practice and a mechanism that detects difficulty early, a child may pass through the school years without reaching the required level.
Here the paradox appears: a system may succeed in bringing a pupil to the end of a stage without succeeding, to the same degree, in ensuring that the pupil possesses the skills that stage was meant to yield. This is not a uniquely Algerian problem, but it is among the most important questions that reform in Algeria must answer.
4.4 From Quantitative Expansion to the Challenge of Quality
The faster an education system expands, the more teachers, inspectors, administrators, buildings and textbooks it needs. If the training of human resources and the improvement of management do not grow at the same pace, a gap opens between the size of the system and its capacity to assure quality. This is a plausible explanation for some of Algeria’s challenges, but it needs to be tested at the level of provinces and educational stages rather than treated as a fixed fact about every school.
Continued reliance on indicators such as enrolment, pass rates and the number of schools, without regular publication of clear results on mastery of reading, arithmetic and science, makes it difficult to locate the fault precisely. If pupils’ results decline, we need to know whether the cause lies in weak comprehension from the earliest years, in teaching methods, in curricula, in classroom density, in social inequality, or in the transition between stages. Without this information, reform is prone to repeated changes of textbooks or programmes that leave the underlying problem untouched.
Part 5: Algeria as a Baseline — What We Know and What We Do Not
The comparison should not begin by assuming that Algeria lags in every dimension of education, nor that it has progressed sufficiently merely because enrolment is high. Each dimension has its own indicators, and every indicator has its year and its limits.
5.1 Expanded Enrolment and Public Investment
UNICEF’s report on Algeria notes that education has become the second-largest investment in the national budget, and that public investment in the sector reached 14.5 per cent in 2023, according to the report’s own definition. It also notes improved primary enrolment and a narrowing of some gender gaps, alongside persistent challenges of learning quality and dropout. In its 2024 report it states that public spending on education stood at 6.3 per cent of gross domestic product. The figure of 14.5 per cent must not be compared directly with 6.3 per cent: the first is a share of the public budget according to the 2023 report, the second a share of gross domestic product according to the 2024 report.
5.2 Completion and Dropout
UNICEF data drawn from the 2019 Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey show differences between educational stages, between urban and rural areas, and between males and females. They indicated that completion of primary education was higher than completion of the intermediate and secondary stages, with risks of dropout among certain groups. These are historical reference data, not a direct measurement of the situation in 2026, and updating them requires clarifying whether they measure enrolment, attendance or completion of a stage.
5.3 Reading Skills and Actual Learning
In its 2022 brief on learning poverty in Algeria, built on older data, the World Bank estimated the rate at about 67.9 per cent: that is, a large share of children at the end of primary-school age had not reached the minimum level of reading under the methodology used. The brief relied on data available up to about 2021, so the figure cannot be treated as a fresh estimate for 2026. It nevertheless remains significant, because it illustrates the difference between providing a school place and ensuring that reading and comprehension are actually acquired.
5.4 Where Does Algeria Stand Relatively?
The sources used here do not contain uniform, up-to-date data that would allow Algeria to be placed at a precise rank among the countries of the sample on all the required dimensions. Three responsible observations can nonetheless be drawn. First, Algeria has an extensive school system and substantial public funding, according to UNICEF data. Second, historical data point to a gap between school enrolment and the acquisition of basic reading skills. Third, it cannot be asserted that Algeria is closer to Japan or to Niger in the quality of learning without recent, consistent data on reading, mathematics, science, dropout and teaching conditions.
The fitting judgement, then, is neither that Algeria is “a complete failure” nor that it is “sufficiently advanced”. It is that Algeria has a broad educational base on which to build, together with an urgent need to measure and improve the quality of learning.
5.5 Open Research Questions
The following hypotheses are framed as questions, not as prior verdicts. Answering them requires recent data from the Ministry of National Education and the National Office of Statistics, from UNESCO and the World Bank, and field studies where published data are lacking:
- 1. Does classroom density explain part of the weakness of individual follow-up?
- 2. Is there a gap between teachers’ preparation and the demands of the curricula?
- 3. Are repeated grade repetition and dropout linked to the difficulty of moving between stages?
- 4. Do the language of instruction and the movement among Arabic, French and English affect the acquisition of knowledge?
- 5. Does private tutoring reflect unequal teaching quality among pupils?
- 6. Do the outputs of university and vocational training match the needs of the economy?
- 7. Does spending yield an educational effect proportionate to its size?
- 8. Do geographic and social disparities affect opportunities to learn?
Part 6: Where Do the Problems of Algerian Education Lie? Six Areas of Concern
The article proposes dividing the problems into six areas, distinguishing between what the available indicators support and what requires more recent national data.
6.1 Weak Acquisition of Basic Skills
The problem is that some pupils advance to higher stages without sufficient mastery of reading, comprehension and arithmetic. The evidence is the historical learning-poverty indicator published by the World Bank for Algeria. What is required is an updated measurement, together with identification of the grades and skills at which pupils begin to falter. This area is especially important because learning is cumulative: what is not mastered in the early years is hard to make up later.
6.2 Uneven Teaching Conditions
The possible problem is variation in class size, resources, availability of specialist teachers and working conditions between schools. What is required is data by province, stage and school; classroom density cannot be treated as a general cause without knowing where it occurs and how it affects pupils’ results.
6.3 Inadequate Linguistic and Scientific Coordination
The possible problem is a set of gaps between the language of learning at different stages and the language a student needs in order to follow university and research literature. What is required is a measurement of actual competence in Arabic, French and English, tied to scientific comprehension, in place of turning the debate into a contest over identity.
6.4 The Dominance of Examination Success over Deep Learning
The possible problem is an emphasis on recalling information and memorising answers at the expense of explaining and applying them. What is required is an analysis of actual textbooks and examinations to establish how much understanding, reasoning and problem-solving they demand, rather than assuming that all teaching rests on rote learning.
6.5 The Gap between Certificate and Skill
The possible problem is a mismatch between some outputs of education and training and the requirements of occupations, research and production. What is required is the tracking of graduates after completion, the measurement of employment and use of skills, and consultation with employers and universities.
6.6 Possible Shortcomings in Measuring Results and Accountability
The problem is the difficulty of distinguishing between increased resources and real improvement in pupils’ learning where regular, independent and comparable data are lacking. What is required is a national system for assessing foundational skills, the publication of aggregated results, and their use to improve schools rather than to penalise teachers mechanically.
It is important to note that these six areas are not all established to the same degree. Weakness in basic skills is supported by historical indicators, whereas the extent of the influence of class size, the nature of examinations or the vocational skills gap requires more recent national studies before the scale of each problem can be estimated or ranked.
Part 7: What Explains Differences in the Level of Education? Factors and a Causal Model
International studies present a picture more complex than the notion that a rich country necessarily has good education, or that a poor country cannot produce scientists. UNESCO reports indicate that the quality of education cannot be reduced to test scores; it includes the preparation of teachers, infrastructure, a safe environment, and the ability to provide genuine learning opportunities for all.
7.1 An Explanatory Framework in Five Links
The relationship among the factors can be imagined as a chain of five links, beginning with general conditions and ending with long-range outcomes:
- 1. Economic, social and institutional conditions: income, child health, stability, inequality and governance.
- 2. Educational resources and capacities: effective funding, qualified teachers, curricula, schools and equipment.
- 3. Learning processes inside the school: teaching, interaction, feedback, attendance and assessment.
- 4. Educational outcomes: reading, mathematics and science, completion of schooling, and skills.
- 5. Long-term economic and scientific outcomes: productivity, innovation, scientific research, income and well-being.
This model shows that effects may be reciprocal. Good education may raise productivity and income, while higher income allows better education to be financed. Scientific research may strengthen the economy, which in turn provides additional funding for research. Sharply separating the factors from one another therefore distorts the picture, and the direction of influence must always be questioned.
7.2 The Factors by Analytical Importance
Table 5: Factors shaping learning by analytical importance
| Factor | Analytical importance | Reason for attention |
|---|---|---|
| Quality of teaching and teacher preparation | Direct | Shape how skills are acquired |
| Acquisition of reading and arithmetic in the early years | Direct and long-term | Affects the pupil’s ability to learn later subjects |
| Equity in the distribution of resources | Direct and indirect | Prevents learning opportunities from concentrating in particular groups |
| Governance and efficiency of spending | Institutional | Determine how far funding turns into actual learning |
| Nutrition, health and poverty | Social | Affect attendance, concentration and persistence |
| Class size | Context-dependent | Its effect depends on the teacher, teaching method and resources |
| Curricula, language and assessment | Direct | Determine the kind of knowledge and skills acquired |
| Academic and research freedom | Institutional and long-term | Linked to an environment of innovation and the development of knowledge |
| National income level | Enabling | Widens possibilities but does not guarantee efficient use |
| Crime and violence | Varies by type and context | May affect safety, attendance and continuity of study |
This table is not a fixed global ranking. Identifying the most influential factor in Algeria calls for an analysis different from that required for Finland or Niger, because the starting point, the resources and the basic problems differ. These hypotheses are not equal in the strength of their evidence, and they do not operate independently: a large budget may bring no clear improvement if spending is ineffective; a small class may be of little benefit if the teacher is unqualified; and a system may produce high examination scores alongside heavy psychological pressure or wide social inequality.
7.3 Living Standards and the Level of Education
Gross domestic product per capita at purchasing-power parity, together with indicators of poverty and health, should be used alongside education indicators, rather than relying on nominal gross domestic product. The analytical cases below show why living standards and education should not be merged into a single index:
Table 6: Analytical cases relating living standards to learning
| Case | What may be observed | Interpretive question |
|---|---|---|
| High income, high learning | Good funding and strong services | Are resources distributed efficiently and fairly? |
| High income, middling learning outcomes | Large resources without results comparable to some advanced systems | Is there a gap in curricula, implementation or the distribution of resources? |
| Middle income, relatively high learning | Good results despite limited resources compared with wealthy countries | Which institutional and pedagogical practices explain this? |
| Low income, low enrolment or learning | Financial constraints and weak infrastructure | Which interventions are most urgent: access to school, improved learning, or both? |
| High enrolment, weak reading skills | Children are in school without acquiring basic skills | Is the problem in teaching, curricula, language or assessment? |
These are analytical cases, not a final classification of any country, and each must be tested against national data before it is attributed to a particular country. The last case is the closest to the question this article raises about Algeria, with the reservation that confirming it requires recent data.
7.4 Class Size: Do Smaller Classes Yield Better Learning?
This is among the most important and most confusing questions, but the scientific answer is not that the fewer the pupils the higher the level of education, automatically. The OECD reports that the average class in which the language of instruction is taught contained about 26 pupils across OECD countries taking part in PISA 2022, with large variation between systems: some classes in Viet Nam, Cambodia and the Philippines had 40 pupils or more, whereas in Finland, Switzerland and Malta they had 20 or fewer. These figures do not mean that class size alone explains differences in results; it suffices to recall that Viet Nam, with its large classes, achieved strong results in PISA 2022.
When a class is crowded, the time available per pupil may shrink, individual errors become harder to follow, and the administrative and behavioural burden on the teacher grows; the danger increases where resources are limited or pupils’ levels vary widely. When a class is smaller, the scope for feedback and individual attention improves, but the benefit depends on changes in teaching that exploit the smaller number, not on the number alone. In nurturing gifted pupils, a suitable class size helps to discover talent, but laboratories, libraries, specialist teachers, university education and research funding are additional essential factors.
A review by the Education Endowment Foundation in Britain shows that evidence for the effect of reducing class size is mixed, that the benefit of reducing numbers alone may be modest relative to its cost, and that benefits emerge more clearly when the change enables more interactive teaching and better follow-up, particularly for some disadvantaged groups.
Linking density to dropout requires distinguishing three indicators: class size, meaning the number of pupils who receive a lesson together; the pupil–teacher ratio, which is not necessarily equal to class size; and school dropout, the share of pupils who leave before completing a given stage. Crowded classes may be associated with difficulties in learning and interaction, but dropout may also be tied to poverty, early work, distance from school, repeated grade repetition, language difficulties, and an education that fails to meet the pupil’s needs. To establish the effect of density one must analyse school-level and regional data rather than rely on a national average, and check whether crowded classes are concentrated in schools that already lack teachers and resources, since such overlap may inflate the apparent relationship between density and results.
7.5 The Teacher: Pay, Qualification and Professional Stability
Comparing nominal salaries is not enough: a teacher with a high salary in a costly country may not enjoy much greater purchasing power than a teacher elsewhere. A sound comparison takes in net pay after taxes and living costs; pay relative to the average earnings of people with similar qualifications; conditions of recruitment, promotion and job security; the quality of pre-service and in-service training; teaching hours and work outside the classroom; the proportion of teachers who specialise in the subjects they teach; and the ability to attract and retain talent in remote areas.
UNESCO data published in 2026 indicate that pre-primary and primary teachers in some cases earn less than workers in other occupations with comparable qualifications, and that their workload includes many hours of preparation, marking and administration. The conclusion is that raising teachers’ pay may be necessary to attract talent and improve stability, but it is not sufficient without good selection of teachers, effective training, sound school management and workable curricula.
7.6 Public Spending: Does More Money Mean Better Quality?
Four financial indicators must be distinguished: expenditure on education as a share of gross domestic product; as a share of total government expenditure; spending per pupil adjusted for price differences; and the distribution of spending among salaries, infrastructure, training, books, technology and research. Data in the 2026 Global Education Monitoring Report show that the global median of public spending on education was 4.2 per cent of gross domestic product in 2024, against 4.3 per cent in 2010, and that only 41 of the 183 countries with data met both reference benchmarks: allocating at least 4 per cent of gross domestic product and at least 15 per cent of public expenditure to education.
These ratios, however, do not measure the efficiency of spending. A country may devote a large share of its budget to wages while needing to build or repair schools, and another may spend on equipment without providing the training needed to use it. The assessment of each country should therefore include a table showing spending by year, educational stage and type of expenditure, compared with learning outcomes and dropout, with attention to differences in accounting definitions between countries.
7.7 National Independence, Academic Freedom and Institutions
The countries compared differ greatly in their systems of government, freedom of expression, university independence and the relationship between state and school. It cannot be assumed, however, that the relationship between democracy and education is linear or identical in all countries. It is more fruitful to test specific mechanisms. Does freedom of debate permit the teaching of critical thinking and the development of research? Does university autonomy protect the choice of scientific topics and the publication of results? Does institutional stability allow educational reforms to continue across governments? Do accountability and transparency help reduce waste and corruption in school management? Can different systems achieve institutional discipline while preserving creativity and independent research?
Three concepts should also be separated: the quality of school education, academic freedom, and political freedom of expression. They may overlap, but they are not identical indicators. National independence enabled many countries to redesign their curricula and expand education, but it does not by itself ensure the building of high-quality educational institutions; post-independence policies, implementation capacity, stability, resources and the colonial legacy must be examined case by case.
7.8 School Safety and Social Behaviour
This axis requires particular caution, for “moral decline” is not a unified statistical indicator and cannot be used alone in international comparison. It is better to break the subject into measurable indicators: school violence and bullying; recorded crime and rates of violence; attendance, discipline and dropout; mental health and the sense of safety; trust in institutions and civic participation; and family circumstances, poverty and social inequality.
Violence may directly affect the regularity of study and pupils’ sense of safety, while some forms of school disengagement may be linked to other social risks; but the relationship may run in both directions and is shaped by poverty, marginalisation, the labour market and the quality of institutions. UNESCO’s 2026 Global Education Monitoring Report stresses the importance of a safe school environment and notes the prevalence of bullying in a large number of countries with data. Crime rates should accordingly not be interpreted as direct evidence of lower intelligence in a population or of poorer schools; the specific links among school security, absenteeism, attainment and dropout should be studied instead.
7.9 Scientists and Gifted Individuals: Can They Be Linked to Their Schools?
They can, provided that we distinguish between where a person’s education began and the institutions that actually contributed to forming the scientist. A scientist may begin schooling in a local primary school, receive secondary and university training elsewhere and conduct research in foreign laboratories; attributing the whole achievement to the first school is an inaccurate simplification. Each scientist should therefore be traced through the stages of life: identity and field; first school; secondary and higher education; research environment and funders; the specific achievement; and relationship to the national system, whether the person studied and worked at home, emigrated, or returned.
This method prevents confusion between the number of scientists born in a country, the number educated there, and the number who continue to work in its research institutions. The number of recipients of scientific prizes must likewise not be read as a direct measure of the quality of basic education, since it is shaped by population size, the history of universities, research funding, migration, scientific publishing networks and the criteria of the prizes themselves.
Part 8: Why Do Educational Reforms Stall? The Deeper Causes
8.1 Reforming the System Rather Than Reforming Learning
A curriculum, a textbook or an examination system may change while daily teaching practice remains as it was. The form of the lesson in official documents may differ from the reality of the classroom, especially when the teacher is required to complete a long programme in limited time. Genuine reform is not the issuing of a new document but a change in what happens inside the classroom. What does the pupil understand? How does the teacher discover the pupil’s mistakes? How often does the pupil practise reading, writing and calculation? Can the pupil apply what has been learned to a new problem? If these practices do not change, reforms may become administrative alterations whose effects never reach the learner.
8.2 Overloaded Curricula and the Problem of Time
When a programme contains a great deal of information and the teacher must finish it within a rigid calendar, speed in delivering lessons may come to matter more than confirming understanding. A vicious circle forms: a dense programme and limited time lead to hurried explanation and insufficient practice, then to an accumulation of gaps in understanding, and then to heavier reliance on memorisation and private tutoring. This is an explanatory model whose applicability to current Algerian curricula must be verified; it is not an established description of every subject and grade. The logical remedy, however, is to give priority to foundational knowledge and to provide adequate time for practice and application, instead of measuring a curriculum’s success by the quantity of information the pupil has passed through.
8.3 The Teacher between Responsibility and Means
Education cannot be reformed by blaming teachers, nor can the systems of training and administration be absolved of responsibility. Teachers need specialist knowledge, the ability to explain and assess, time for preparation, suitable resources, continuing training, and a management that helps them solve problems. When classes are large or pupils’ levels diverge, individual follow-up becomes harder. Conversely, improving professional conditions alone is not enough unless it is accompanied by the development of teaching skills and by monitoring the effect of training on pupils’ results.
UNESCO estimates that the world needs 44 million additional teachers to achieve universal primary and secondary education by 2030, in its projections linked to the Sustainable Development Goals, and stresses that the problem concerns the quality of teachers and the conditions of the profession, not their number alone. For Algeria, reform should begin by auditing data on recruitment, specialisations, training and working conditions, and then directing resources to actual areas of shortage, rather than adopting uniform solutions for all schools.
8.4 The Certificate as an End Rather Than Evidence of Competence
The problem worsens when the pupil’s aim becomes success in the examination, the family’s aim a high average mark, and the institution’s aim a good pass rate, without any measurement of what the pupil can do with the knowledge acquired. This does not mean that examinations are unnecessary; it means that an examination should measure understanding, reasoning and application, not only the recall of information. If a pupil can solve a memorised exercise but is unable to handle a similar problem worded differently, success in the first does not prove that the skill has been durably acquired. This area requires a review of actual Algerian examination papers, a classification of questions by level of thinking, and a comparison of results between school tests and independent assessments.
8.5 Social Inequality and Private Tutoring
When one family can afford additional lessons and another cannot, opportunities to learn become partly dependent on a family’s financial capacity. Private tutoring may benefit some pupils, but it becomes a systemic problem when it turns into a near-necessary condition for understanding or passing the curriculum. The aim is not to oppose families that seek to improve their children’s prospects but to ensure that the public school delivers sufficient, high-quality education during official school hours.
The scale of household spending on private tutoring in Algeria should be studied, along with differences between provinces and stages and the reasons for resorting to it: weak understanding, a dense programme, competition for high marks, or the desire to excel. Without such data, it will not be possible to determine the most effective policy.
Part 9: What Risks Threaten Algerian Education if the Problems Persist?
9.1 The Accumulation of Learning Gaps
A pupil who does not master reading in the early years faces greater difficulty later in understanding science, history and geography. If the gap is not addressed early, it may harden into cumulative failure that is hard to remedy in the upper stages.
9.2 Widening Disparities among Pupils
The differences may grow between those who receive family support and private lessons and those who depend on the school alone. This threatens the principle of equal opportunity even if public education remains free.
9.3 Weak Alignment between Education and the Economy
If graduates lack the skills institutions require, a shortage of certain competences may coexist with unemployment among certificate holders. This should be measured by specialisation, occupation and region, not assumed to affect all certificates alike.
9.4 A Reduced Capacity to Produce Knowledge and Innovation
Scientific research needs a strong school foundation, good university education, laboratories and funding, and freedom of inquiry and exchange of knowledge. If one link in this chain fails, it is difficult to turn the number of graduates into research and productive strength.
9.5 Declining Trust in the Public School
When families feel that success depends on resources outside the school, their confidence may fall in the school’s ability to provide good education for all. This can strengthen demand for parallel education and deepen social inequality.
9.6 Repeated Reforms without Measurable Results
If reforms are not coupled with clear indicators and independent review of results, the form of the system may change without its underlying problems being addressed, and time and money are lost on adjustments whose effect is difficult to evaluate.
These are possible risks, not inevitable forecasts. They can be reduced if education policy moves from monitoring inputs alone to monitoring actual learning, with respect for the circumstances of teachers and pupils and for the financial capacities of the state.
Part 10: Realistic Solutions That Suit Algeria without Colliding with Social Identity or State Choices
The reform of Algerian education does not require copying the Finnish or Japanese model in full, nor a radical change in the structure of the state or the identity of the school. Gradual reforms can be implemented within the existing public system, with the participation of teachers, families, universities and economic sectors. Above all, the solutions must be specific and measurable, not general slogans such as “improving quality” or “developing curricula”.
10.1 Solution One: Prioritising Reading and Mathematics in the Early Years
The proposal is a national programme for the first three years of primary education, focused on mastery of reading, comprehension, writing and basic arithmetic. The programme would include:
- A short diagnostic test at the start of the year, not used to penalise pupil or teacher.
- Grouping of pupils by the skills they need to develop, not by a fixed label of ability.
- Short, regular support sessions for struggling pupils inside the school.
- Practical teaching guides for teachers, with graded reading materials and exercises.
- Periodic assessment to establish the proportion of pupils who have genuinely improved.
This can be done without changing the language of instruction or abolishing the national curricula. What is required is a reordering of priorities and the provision of time for remedial learning.
10.2 Solution Two: Lightening the Curricular Load Rather Than Adding Programmes
Each subject should be reviewed in the light of a clear question: what must the pupil actually master by the end of this level? The content of the curriculum should then be sorted into three categories: essential knowledge and skills that cannot be dispensed with; important content that requires understanding and application; and content that can be reduced or deferred if it crowds out foundational skills. The result of reform must not be an increase in the number of lessons or activities required of the teacher, but the freeing of time for explanation, application and revision.
10.3 Solution Three: Developing Teachers through In-School Training
Instead of relying on general courses, small teaching teams could be organised within schools or among neighbouring schools, working to:
- Review pupils’ errors in reading, arithmetic and science.
- Observe and analyse model lessons that have succeeded.
- Exchange lesson plans and exercises.
- Administer short tests before and after a lesson.
- Train new teachers to deal with individual differences.
Training should be evaluated by the improvement in pupils’ performance and by observation of classroom practice, not merely by the number of training hours or certificates awarded.
10.4 Solution Four: Addressing Overcrowding Where It Does the Most Harm to Learning
It is unrealistic for Algeria to begin by reducing all classes to a single uniform size, because this would require additional buildings, teachers and funding, and might not be the best use of resources in every region. It is better to conduct a survey by school and stage, and then to give priority to classes that combine high density with weak foundational skills and high repetition or absenteeism, while studying the need for additional teachers, the division of cohorts or the reorganisation of timetables. In this way policy rests on actual need, not on an assumption that every large class suffers the same problem.
10.5 Solution Five: A Graduated and Clear National Language Policy
Algeria can preserve Arabic as the principal national language while strengthening pupils’ proficiency in foreign languages. This requires:
- Good teaching of Arabic, especially reading, comprehension and writing.
- Development of Arabic scientific terminology and textbooks at the stages where science is taught in Arabic.
- Effective teaching of French and English, focused on comprehension, communication and scientific reading.
- Coordination between secondary and university education so that students are not surprised by an unprepared linguistic transition.
- Measurement of real linguistic competence rather than reliance on school marks alone.
Such a policy does not entail abolishing one language in favour of another; it removes the contradiction between what the student learns and what the student will need at the next stage.
10.6 Solution Six: Rebuilding Assessment and Examinations Gradually
Assessments should combine the measurement of foundational knowledge with the measurement of the ability to use it. In mathematics, for example, a test might include direct calculation questions, a problem drawn from everyday life, and a question asking the pupil to explain the steps of the solution. In science, the pupil might be asked to read a table or interpret the result of a simple experiment. This does not mean dispensing with national examinations, but developing them so that they measure what pupils ought to learn and align with the curricula, rather than pushing pupils to memorise model answers.
10.7 Solution Seven: Linking Spending More Closely to Results
Clear data on spending on education should be published by stage, province and type of expenditure, and linked to indicators such as attendance, completion, and mastery of reading and mathematics. The free character of public education can be preserved while additional support is directed to schools with greater needs, such as a shortage of teachers, difficulty of access or high rates of learning difficulty. The effect of purchasing equipment and digital tools should also be evaluated before they are generalised, since a device or a platform does not improve learning automatically in the absence of maintenance, training and suitable content.
10.8 Solution Eight: Strengthening Vocational Education and Linking It to Production
Vocational education should not be a track to which pupils who failed in the academic stream are pushed; it should be a respected option leading to sought-after skills and certificates of real value. This requires partnerships between training institutions and economic sectors, practical training, updated specialisations, and information about job opportunities and wages after graduation. Movement between tracks must also remain possible, so that an early choice does not become a permanent constraint on the pupil.
10.9 Solution Nine: Building an Independent National System for Assessing Learning
Algeria needs regular, representative assessments of pupils in the basic grades, with results published in aggregate form and showing differences among provinces, regions and schools without stigmatising them. The assessments should preferably combine reading and comprehension; mathematics and reasoning; science and the application of knowledge; attendance and completion of stages; and indicators of learning conditions and the availability of teachers. The results must not become a punitive ranking of schools, since this may lead some institutions to concentrate on figures at the expense of learning. They should instead be used to identify needs, direct support and monitor improvement.
Part 11: A Five-Year Implementation Plan and the Question of Resistance
11.1 A Phased Five-Year Plan
The table below is a policy proposal; it is neither an announced government plan nor an official financial estimate.
Table 7: A phased five-year plan
| Phase | Priority measures | Indicators of success |
|---|---|---|
| Year One | A national measurement of reading and arithmetic, and a survey of density, specialisations and resources | A published, comparable baseline |
| Year Two | Piloting support for foundational skills in a diverse sample of schools | Measured improvement against the baseline, comparing pilot schools with a similar group |
| Year Three | Extending the programmes that proved successful and developing teacher training | An increased share of pupils reaching the basic threshold in reading and mathematics |
| Year Four | Reviewing curricula and examinations and expanding work-linked vocational training | Improved application skills and higher quality of practical training |
| Year Five | An independent evaluation of results and costs, and adjustment of policies | Sustained improvement, narrower disparities and better use of resources |
It is preferable to implement this plan gradually in provinces with different conditions, including urban and rural areas, so that national policy is not built on the experience of a single school or a single region.
11.2 Reforms That May Meet Social Resistance
Any educational reform may fail if it ignores society, however technically persuasive it may be.
Table 8: Reforms likely to meet social resistance, and how to reduce it
| Possible measure | Source of resistance | How to reduce it |
|---|---|---|
| Lightening the curricula | Fear of lowered standards or the removal of important knowledge | Publishing the rationale for change, specifying the skills that will improve, and involving teachers and families |
| Developing examinations | Anxiety about changes to the criteria of success | Gradual implementation, published models, and training of teachers and pupils |
| Regulating private tutoring | Families’ fear of losing a means of supporting their children | Improving official teaching and providing free support sessions before regulatory measures are taken |
| Adjusting language policy | Sensitivities tied to national identity | Securing the standing of Arabic, clarifying the function of foreign languages and avoiding exclusionary rhetoric |
| Evaluating schools | Fear of punishment or public shaming | Using results for improvement, protecting data, and not reducing a school’s performance to a single indicator |
| Redirecting the budget | Competition for resources among provinces and stages | Publishing fair criteria for additional funding and tying it to actual need |
The general rule is that a reform which asks a family or a teacher to change behaviour must offer a persuasive practical alternative, rather than merely issuing new instructions.
Part 12: What Should Algeria Not Import? Distinguishing Real Causes from Comfortable Explanations
12.1 What Should Not Be Imported
A common error is to turn a successful experience into a complete ideal model. Japan and South Korea have achieved strong academic performance, but there is no need to import everything associated with their culture of examinations and competition. Finland offers important lessons in teacher preparation and equity, but applying its policies requires attention to the size of the system, its resources and its institutions. Viet Nam offers a useful experience in some aspects of learning, but its results do not mean that its system is free of disparities or that all its indicators equal those of the best-performing countries.
What should be transferred is the specific practice whose benefit has been demonstrated, after verifying that it can be applied in Algeria. If a field trial shows that early support sessions raise reading skills at reasonable cost, they can be extended. If it emerges that reducing class size in a given area does not yield an improvement that justifies its cost, the policy should be adjusted rather than continued simply because it was inspired by a successful country.
12.2 Six Comfortable Explanations That Call for Criticism
- 1. The whole problem lies with the teacher. This explanation reduces the system to a single individual and ignores curricula, training, resources and management. The teacher is a pivotal element, but works within an institution that defines what is possible.
- 2. The whole problem is classroom density. Density may be an influential factor, but class size alone does not explain the level of learning; the interaction among pupil numbers, quality of teaching and resources should be studied.
- 3. The whole problem is language. The language of instruction matters, but educational outcomes are also shaped by the quality of textbooks, training, learning time, assessment and social background; it cannot be shown without evidence that changing one language would solve the problem.
- 4. A larger budget will cure everything. Funding is necessary, but its effect depends on how it is distributed and used; some organisational and pedagogical reforms may have greater impact than purchasing more equipment.
- 5. The cause is weak moral discipline. This is an unmeasurable generalisation; instead, absenteeism, school violence, bullying, classroom climate and family circumstances should be studied through clear indicators.
- 6. The solution is a return to the methods of the past. Some traditional practices may be useful, but restoring them without evaluation guarantees nothing; what is needed is a combination of clear foundational knowledge, repeated practice, and thinking and analysis, in line with what the evidence supports.
Part 13: The Final Judgement — What Is Algeria’s Highest Priority?
If a single priority must be chosen, it is to secure the acquisition of reading, comprehension and arithmetic in the first years of schooling, and then to build the remaining reforms around that goal. The reason is that these skills are not merely school subjects; they are the instruments a pupil needs to understand science, history and geography, to continue through secondary and university education, to train for an occupation, and to draw on scientific sources.
Yet this choice does not mean neglecting the teacher, the curricula, language or funding. It means arranging them within an integrated plan: a teacher able to teach, a curriculum that prioritises essentials, enough time for practice, an assessment that reveals difficulty, and early support for the pupils who need it. At the same time, results must not become a means of condemning schools or teachers; they should serve as a tool for directing support and improving practice.
Conclusion
A Strong National School, Not Merely a School That Awards Certificates
The expansion of education after independence was a major achievement in the building of Algerian society, and its value should not be diminished. But the present stage requires a move from the question “How many children entered school?” to harder questions: What did they learn? What can they apply? And does a poor pupil in a remote region receive as good a learning opportunity as a pupil living in better circumstances?
Comparison with Japan, South Korea, Finland and Viet Nam does not mean that Algeria must abandon its identity or its public system; it means that it can benefit from practices that can be adapted to its own reality. And comparison with countries suffering graver crises should not breed a false sense of satisfaction; it should remind us of the importance of protecting the continuity and quality of education.
To speak plainly, the greatest danger to Algerian education is not the acknowledgement that problems exist, but becoming accustomed to them, explaining them by single causes, or undertaking reforms without knowing whether they have genuinely improved what pupils learn.
A good school is not one that completes the largest number of lessons, nor one that achieves the highest pass rate on paper. It is one that gives the child firm knowledge, the capacity to think, skill in expression, confidence in learning and a fair chance to build a future. This is an aim that can be pursued within public education, national identity and the available resources, on condition that improvement in pupils’ learning becomes the principal criterion by which educational decisions are judged, rather than the mere number of reforms that institutions announce.
A Final Note
Some of the Algerian indicators cited in this article are historical and are not measurements for 2026. The ordering of priorities here is therefore based on analysis of the available evidence, whereas estimating the size of each problem today and the cost of remedying it requires recent and detailed national data by stage, province and school.
References
- World Bank: the education sector and learning indicators, including learning poverty and quality of education; data on gross domestic product per capita at purchasing-power parity.
- UNICEF: Education and Adolescent Development in Algeria; UNICEF Algeria Annual Report 2024.
- Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development: PISA 2022 Results, and country notes, including that for Viet Nam.
- UNESCO: Global Education Monitoring Report (quality of education), and the UNESCO Institute for Statistics database.
- UNESCO International Institute for Educational Planning.
- Education Endowment Foundation: evidence review on reducing class size.
- Carnegie Endowment for International Peace: the politics of language in Algerian education.
- World Education Services: the history of the education system in Algeria and its development after independence.